American Hartford Gold Vs. Birch Gold Group

When people think about spreading their investments to stay safe from market ups and downs, many look at precious metals like gold. American Hartford Gold vs. Birch Gold Group are two big companies in this market.

American Hartford Gold is quite popular for helping investors buy, sell, and keep precious metals safe, with a touch of family business warmth.

Meanwhile, Birch Gold Group offers a wide range of services, focusing on helping investors with gold IRAs and tailored advice based on thorough market research.

Both have a solid reputation and extensive experience and aim to help investors make smart choices. This comparison will highlight their main differences, helping potential investors decide which company might better suit their needs.

STOP! Before I go any further, I want you to think carefully about where you’re putting your money. Picking the right company to invest with is a big deal, and I know my advice might help you decide that.

I’ve spent much time looking around and compiled a list of my favorite gold IRA companies. I think you’ll probably find one that’s just right for you.

>> CLICK HERE to check out my list of the 10 Best Gold IRA Companies <<

Find out if “American Hartford Gold and Birch Gold Group” made it to my list this year!


Click the button below for a FREE Gold IRA Kit from my most trusted provider:

Get The FREE Gold IRA Kit Americans Are Using To Protect Their Retirement Savings…

– Join the Thousands Who Have Safeguarded Over 2 Billion Dollars in Savings with This Gold IRA Kit! –

Quick Overview

  • CEO: Sanford Mann
  • BBB: 4.89/5 Out of 521 Customer Reviews
  • Available Metals: Gold, Silver, Platinum, and Palladium
  • Minimum Investment: $10,000
  • Promotions: Get Up to $5,000 in Free Silver on Qualified Purchases
  • Free Kit Available: Yes
  • CEO: Laith Alsarraf
  • BBB: 4.39/5 Out of 110 Customer Reviews
  • Available Metals: Gold, Silver, Platinum, and Palladium
  • Minimum Investment: $10,000
  • Promotions: The Company Sometimes Offers Promotions
  • Free Kit Available: Yes
Disclosure: “The owners of this website may be paid to recommend Goldco or other companies. The content on this website, including any positive reviews of Goldco and other reviews, may not be neutral or independent.”

What is American Hartford Gold?

In 2015, Sanford Mann founded American Hartford Gold. With a big goal, he aimed to create a trustworthy and honest business that really cared about helping its customers.

He focused on making investments in metals like gold and silver more personal, wanting to meet the unique needs of everyone who came to him.

The company is located in Los Angeles, California, and has become quite popular over the last decade. It started because there was a growing interest in investing in different things beyond the usual stocks and bonds, especially when the economy isn’t stable or when prices are rising.

They are known for being a company that really cares about its customers. This is shown in all the good things people say about them online and their high ratings.

The company’s main goal is to ensure that its customers understand how investing in metals works. They put much effort into teaching and providing excellent service, ensuring people feel comfortable and safe with their investments.

Famous people, like Bill O’Reilly, have supported the company, making it even more trusted and well-known. It’s also been talked about in major money and investment magazines, helping it become a top name in the world of metal markets.

Through all this, American Hartford Gold’s biggest aim continues to educate its clients on metal investment and ensure they have a good experience and secure investment options.

If you would like to learn more about the company:

What is Birch Gold Group?

They have become a notable name in the US for selling precious metals like gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.

It was founded in 2003 and based in Burbank, California; the company is recognized for its strong ethical standards and has earned a high rating with the Better Business Bureau, which shows it treats customers well and operates fairly.

They are dedicated to educating their clients about the benefits of precious metals and provide individualized advice and support, ensuring each customer makes informed investment choices.

This commitment to personal service has won the company many loyal clients who trust them with their investments.

Their reputation is also boosted by endorsements from well-known figures like Ben Shapiro, mentioned in top financial publications, which helps people trust their services.

Birch Gold Group doesn’t just sell metals; it excels at offering guidance and useful information, listening carefully to each customer’s needs, and providing advice that best suits them.

The company is led by CEO Laith P. Alsarraf, whose finance and business management background has been key to Birch Gold Group’s success.

He understands the market well and knows how to meet investors’ needs, helping them choose investments in precious metals to secure their money against loss of value and inflation.

Lastly, Birch Gold Group has established itself as a trusted leader in the precious metals market. With a strong leader, years of expertise, and a focus on client education and satisfaction, the company is a reliable choice for those buying precious metals.

If you would like to learn more about the company:
You can check my Birch Gold IRA review.

Types of Services Offered

American Hartford Gold and Birch Gold Group focus on Gold IRAs and selling precious metals, giving personalized help and investment advice.

American Hartford Gold

American Hartford Gold offers several helpful services for both beginners and experienced investors in precious metals, including:

  • Buying Metals: They sell gold and silver in various shapes and sizes, making finding something that suits your budget and investment plans easy.
  • Precious Metals IRA: They help you set up or switch your retirement account to one with precious metals. They’ll guide you to pick the right metals and get everything set up properly.
  • Selling Metals Back: American Hartford Gold also buys precious metals at competitive prices, ensuring you have the flexibility and confidence to manage your investments.
  • Safe Storage: Knowing that keeping your metals safe is crucial, they provide secure storage options across the US where you can keep your gold and silver safely.

Birch Gold Group

Birch Gold Group helps people put their money into precious metals like gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.

They offer a bunch of helpful services:

  • Buying Precious Metals: You can buy precious metals like gold and silver directly from them. They have many types of coins and bars to choose from, and they can send these to your home or keep them safe for you.
  • Putting Precious Metals in Retirement Accounts: They can help you add precious metals to your retirement savings account. This is a good way to make your savings more diverse and secure. They care for all the tricky parts, like picking the best metals and ensuring everything is legal.
  • Selling Metals Back: If you ever need to sell your precious metals, Birch Gold Group can buy them back from you. This might be useful if you need cash quickly or want to change your investment. They can’t tell you exactly how much they’ll pay in advance.
  • Moving Retirement Funds: If you already have retirement money saved in a 401(k), they can help you move it into precious metals without causing tax issues. This service is great for adding precious metals to your retirement plan.

Birch Gold Group makes it easy to invest in precious metals and offers lots of help to ensure you feel good about where your money is going, whether you’re new to this or have been investing for a while.

Fees and Pricing

American Hartford Gold generally waives fees for new clients, while Birch Gold Group has transparent pricing with minimal fees.

Find out all the details below:

American Hartford Gold

You don’t need a lot of money to start. With American Hartford Gold, you can open a cash account with $5,000 or a gold IRA with $10,000.

Details: Amount:
Minimum Investment Needs:
– Gold IRA $10,000
– Cash Account $5,000
Fees Overview:
– Yearly Fee for Safety and Services $100-$150
– Custodian Fee Annually About $180
– Initial Setup Charge $230
– Buyback Program Quick process to sell metals back easily

American Hartford Gold offers low minimum investments, manageable fees, and a quick buyback program, which is ideal for starting in precious metals IRAs.

Birch Gold Group

They stand out for their transparency regarding fees and lower barriers to entry for investors.

Here is an overview of the fee structure at Birch Gold Group:

Fee Type: Amount: Condition:
Annual Account Management Fee: $100 Per year
Account Opening Fee: $50 One-time
Minimum Amount to Invest: $10,000 Initial investment
Wiring Fee: $30 One-time
Annual Storage and Insurance Fee: $100 Per year

This approach to pricing by Birch Gold Group makes it a viable option for a wide range of investors, whether you’re starting small or have a more substantial amount to commit.

The highlight is the fee waiver for the first year on investments exceeding $50,000, coupled with the flat annual fee of $200 after that, which underscores their commitment to transparent and equitable service for every investor.


– Uncover the Top 3 Reasons to Get Your FREE Gold IRA Kit Now –

  1. Learn the Secrets to Protecting Your Savings Without TAXES or PENALTIES
  2. Learn the Strategies to PROTECT & GROW Your Retirement Wealth
  3. Get This Kit Delivered to Your Door for FREE – $0 Shipping & Handling Charges

How to Start Investing

American Hartford Gold and Birch Gold Group are great places to get help and grow your investment. Let’s find out how you can get started with both of them.

American Hartford Gold

Investing in this company is easy, and here’s how you can start:

  1. Learn First: Begin by learning what American Hartford Gold offers. They deal with gold and silver in various forms like bars, coins, and retirement accounts known as gold IRAs.
  2. Get in Touch: Contact them through their website or by phone. They have friendly experts who can answer your questions and guide you on how to invest with them based on your needs.
  3. Explore Options: They will show you different ways to invest. Whether you are thinking about buying metals directly or saving for retirement with a gold IRA, they will help you understand the benefits of each.
  4. Fill Out Forms: Decide to go ahead and fill out some forms. For a gold IRA, this means picking someone to look after your account. American Hartford Gold can help you choose the right one.
  5. Add Money:
    – You need at least $5,000 for a direct purchase account.
    – For a gold IRA, you need at least $10,000.
    – Put your money in the account. They can show you how if you’re moving money from another retirement account.
  6. Pick Your Metals: Next, you choose which metals to buy. American Hartford Gold offers many options and will give you all the information you need to make your choice.
  7. Buy and Store: Once you decide, you’ll buy the metals. For gold IRA investments, they’ll keep your metals safe with a trusted custodian. They make sure your investment is secure and well-protected.
  8. Help Along the Way: Even after you buy, you can always contact them for help, updates, or to sell your metals back if you choose to.

Starting with American Hartford Gold means getting the help you need every step of the way. It’s a good choice whether you’re new to investing in precious metals or looking to add to your investment collection, making the process as easy and beneficial for you as possible.

Birch Gold Group

Here is a step-by-step guide on how to get started with Birch Gold Group:

  1. Learn About Precious Metals: Before you do anything else, learning a bit about precious metals like gold and silver is important. The Birch Gold Group’s website has simple guides and articles to help you understand what they offer and how they work.
  2. Get in Touch: Once you know the basics, contact Birch Gold Group using their online contact form or calling their free phone number. This is when you’ll ask questions and discuss what you want to do with your investments.
  3. Talk to an Expert: They will put you in touch with someone who knows about precious metals. They will chat with you for free to figure out your money situation and how precious metals can be a part of your savings.
  4. Open an Account: If you decide to proceed, the expert will help you open an account. This might be a special account called a “Precious Metals IRA” if you’re saving for retirement. They’ll make sure all the paperwork is sorted out for you.
  5. Add Money to Your Account: Next, you’ll need to deposit money into your new account. You can move money from another savings account or add new money. The expert will ensure that your money transfer goes smoothly.
  6. Choose Your Metals: Now, it’s time to choose the actual gold, silver, or other metals you want. Birch Gold Group has many options, and the expert will help you choose the best ones based on their cost and the market’s conditions.
  7. Keep Your Metals Safe: After you pick your metals, they will help you buy and store them safely. They work with special storage places that keep your metals safe and secure.
  8. Get Help When You Need it: Even after you buy your metals, you can always call Birch Gold Group for help. They can give you updates on your metals or help you change your investment choices later on.

By going through these steps, you’ll get the help you need from Birch Gold Group to start putting precious metals into your savings.

Customer and Third Party Reviews

When considering putting money into precious metals, checking out what others have said about their experiences can help you make a good choice. People’s opinions and stories can lead you to the right decision.

Here’s a simple table to see how American Hartford Gold and Birch Gold Group compare, based on what people have said on different websites:

Website: American Hartford Gold: Birch Gold Group:
Better Business Bureau: A+ (521 reviews) A+ (108 reviews)
Trustpilot: 4.8/5 (1,239 reviews) 4.2/5 (172 reviews)
ConsumerAffairs: 4.7/5 (860 reviews) 5/5 (153 reviews)
Google My Business: 4.8/5 (1,046 reviews) Not shown
Business Consumer Alliance: AAA (9 reviews) AAA (7 reviews)

Birch Gold Group received mixed reviews, praised for excellent service and guidance in precious metals investment, yet criticized by some for significant financial losses on specific assets.

On the other hand, Customers reported mixed experiences with American Hartford Gold. While some appreciated the company’s professionalism and supportive staff, others faced unresolved billing issues, unmet promises about storage, and lack of communication, leading to dissatisfaction and regret over their choice.

Pros and Cons

Both offer special benefits and some downsides for people looking to add gold or other metals to their investment mix. Let’s take a look at them.

American Hartford Gold

Many customers have shared positive experiences, pointing out how the company made their investment process smooth and easy to understand.


  • Great Customer Support: Many people are happy with the swift and helpful responses they receive when they have questions or problems.
  • Good Advice from Experts: The staff knows much about investing in precious metals and helps customers make smart choices.
  • Quick to Fix Issues: When something goes wrong, many customers note that the company is fast to make things right, which helps build trust.
  • Simple Buying Process: American Hartford Gold makes buying gold or silver easy, making customers feel comfortable with their investments.
  • Helpful and Smart Staff: Customers feel supported and informed thanks to the professional and knowledgeable team.


  • Trouble Getting Replies: Some customers mentioned having trouble getting in touch or hearing back on their issues.
  • Billing Mistakes and Unexpected Costs: A few people were upset about billing errors and not getting the promised free storage, leading to extra charges.

To sum up, they are praised for their helpful staff and the support they offer to investors. However, better communication and sticking to their promises could improve their service even more.

Birch Gold Group

This is another company that helps people invest in metals like gold. It’s known for clarifying the investment process and providing helpful advice to clients.


  • Quick and Caring Customer Service: Many customers like how fast the company responds to their questions and helps with their concerns.
  • Advice You Can Trust: The company gives great advice about investing, helping customers make good investment decisions.
  • Clear and Honest Deals: People trust Birch Gold Group because they are open and honest about all the details of buying and selling.
  • Managing Investments is Easy: Customers can access many services that make managing their investments easier and more rewarding.
  • Learn About Investing: A lot of information is available that helps customers understand how to invest in precious metals better.


  • Worries About Losing Money: Some customers are concerned about losing money due to their choices based on advice they received, suggesting a need for clearer explanations of risks.
  • Service Can be Inconsistent: Although many experiences are positive, some people felt the service was not as good as they expected all the time, showing a need for more consistent quality.

In conclusion, they are valued for their responsive customer service and trustworthy investment advice. By ensuring customers fully understand the risks and striving for consistently high-quality service, they can further enhance their reputation.

Which Company Should You Invest with?

Choosing between these two gold investing companies can be tough without knowing your exact needs. But if I had to pick one, my choice would be American Hartford Gold.

They’re known for being really good with their customers, making buying gold and silver easy and helping lots of people add these metals to their investment mix.

They also teach their clients about investing without pressuring them too much, which is great for new and experienced investors. Always remember to check both companies carefully, including their fees, before making your choice.


American Hartford Gold and Birch Gold Group offer different benefits for people interested in gold and silver. They are known for helping customers understand investing and for good prices, which is great for all buyers.

Birch Gold Group provides more detailed help in choosing investments and has more types of metals to buy. Each company is good, depending on what you want from your investment.


Goldco Precious Metals

  • Goldco Surpasses $2 Billion in Precious Metals Placements
  • Over 5,000 Five-Star Ratings on BBB, Trustpilot, and ConsumerAffairs
  • Seven-Time Winer on the Inc. 5000 List


Disclosure: “The owners of this website may be paid to recommend Goldco or other companies. The content on this website, including any positive reviews of Goldco and other reviews, may not be neutral or independent.”
Scroll to Top